Thanksgiving Wine Pairing 2018

By Jimmy Quaile, Certified Sommelier


The long-standing rule of matching wine and food – red wine with meat and white wine with fish – actually has a scientific explanation. Then again, I doubt too many people eat meat or fish without a compliment of side dishes…especially on such a gastronomic feast as Thanksgiving.  So how do you pair the perfect wine for a meal that is a minefield of competing tastes and flavors? Eliminate the biggest one – the turkey!

Thanksgiving turkey being fairly neutral in flavor will pair nicely with a lot of different wines: red, white, and rosé. The real struggle is with the side dishes, and Thanksgiving dinner is more about the sides than the main dish (in my humble opinion). A simple way to go is to pick the side with the most distinct flavor since that will influence the rest of the food on the plate, and match that intensity with the intensity of the wine. Another idea is to look at the whole plate. For example, sweet potatoes, cranberry sauce, and chunks of apples in the stuffing all have sweet elements that can make dry wines taste thin and bitter. The answer: a white wine with a touch of residual sugar or a low-tannin red wine. Now I know what you’re thinking; “You Sommeliers over-think this whole wine and food pairing thing!” – and you may be right. You certainly can drink your favorite wine and leave it at that. But with just a little research or a few recommendations you have the chance to make even the wine something to be thankful for.

What is the difference between  New World and Old World wines? 

“Old World” refers to Europe, while “New World” refers to everything else. Although the difference goes well beyond geography, for the most part, Old World wines favor tradition, are lighter bodied, have better balance, and are thought to be better with food.  Alternatively, New World wines favor innovation, tend to be more full-bodied and fruit-forward.

On such an American holiday you may want to drink all domestic wines. However, if you’d like to be more adventurous, I’ve added some choices from around the world.

Guests Arrive
New World: Gloria Ferrer Brut Rosé $24.98
Old World: Saint-Hilaire Brut $13.98

New World: King Estate Pinot Gris $17.99
Old World: Toricino Greco di Tufo $17.99

Soup & Salad
New World: Ferrari-Carano Fumé Blanc $13.99
Old World: 90+ Cellars Sancerre $15.99

Main Course
New World:
White – Trefethen Chardonnay $28.99
Red – Neyers Sage Canyon Red $23.99

Old World
White – J.M. Boillot Montagny 1er Cru $24.99
Red – Couldoulet de Beaucastel Cotes-Du-Rhône $21.98

New World – Schmitt Söne Icewine $19.99
Old World – Tokaj Classic Late Harvest Cuvée $21.99

Curious to try our recommendations? You can find all of these bottles at Roger Wilco, Pennsauken!

Thanksgiving Wine Pairing UPDATED!
Tagged on:                 
Want Updates on Sales, Recipes, Giveaways & More?
Share Your Email With Us Below!
We respect your privacy.